Car Insurance After an Accident in New York: Rates & Best Companies (2026)
Quick Answer
An at-fault accident in New York increases insurance by 39%, raising full coverage from $3,840/year to $5,338/year. Some companies like Allstate offer accident forgiveness that prevents the first increase.
✓ Updated March 2026✓ Based on state insurance filings
Before Accident
$320/mo
After At-Fault Accident (+39%)
$445/mo
Cheapest Companies After Accident in New York
| Company | Monthly | Annual | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| CheapestUSAA | $329/mo | $3,950/yr | Military families |
| Erie Insurance | $351/mo | $4,217/yr | Rate lock guarantee |
| GEICO | $365/mo | $4,377/yr | Clean driving record |
| Progressive | $391/mo | $4,697/yr | Telematics savings |
| State Farm | $405/mo | $4,858/yr | Good students |
| Travelers | $423/mo | $5,071/yr | Multiple discounts |
| Nationwide | $463/mo | $5,552/yr | Bundling home + auto |
| Farmers | $480/mo | $5,765/yr | Signal telematics |
| Allstate | $498/mo | $5,979/yr | Accident forgiveness |
| Liberty Mutual | $525/mo | $6,299/yr | New car replacement |
USAACheapest
Monthly
$329/mo
Annual
$3,950/yr
Best for: Military families
Erie Insurance
Monthly
$351/mo
Annual
$4,217/yr
Best for: Rate lock guarantee
GEICO
Monthly
$365/mo
Annual
$4,377/yr
Best for: Clean driving record
Progressive
Monthly
$391/mo
Annual
$4,697/yr
Best for: Telematics savings
State Farm
Monthly
$405/mo
Annual
$4,858/yr
Best for: Good students
Travelers
Monthly
$423/mo
Annual
$5,071/yr
Best for: Multiple discounts
Nationwide
Monthly
$463/mo
Annual
$5,552/yr
Best for: Bundling home + auto
Farmers
Monthly
$480/mo
Annual
$5,765/yr
Best for: Signal telematics
Allstate
Monthly
$498/mo
Annual
$5,979/yr
Best for: Accident forgiveness
Liberty Mutual
Monthly
$525/mo
Annual
$6,299/yr
Best for: New car replacement
These are estimates based on state averages. Your exact rate depends on your specific profile.
✓ No spam calls · ✓ No personal info sold · ✓ Takes 2 minutes
How to Lower Rates After an Accident
- Take a defensive driving course (5-10% discount in most states)
- Increase your deductible to $1,000 or higher
- Shop around — rates vary 50%+ between companies after an accident
- Ask about accident forgiveness programs
- Bundle home and auto for additional savings
- Maintain continuous coverage without lapses